Information Research, Vol. 5 No. 2, January 2000
An outline of LIS programs offered by the Department of Information Sciences, Faculty of Philosophy, University of Zagreb is given. Factors affecting the recent curriculum revision are described and the reasons for the introduction of a new course in library legislation and standards have been pointed out. The intention of the course has been to make students aware of the existence of international documents relevant to libraries and librarians and to show how the current trends are reflected in national legislation. It is hoped that the course might help students improve their understanding of the legal context surrounding libraries and other information institutions and teach them to appreciate the importance of good legislation.
Up to 1998 the only LIS programme in Croatia leading to the Bachelor’s degree was organised at the Department of Information Sciences, Faculty of Philosophy, University of Zagreb (1). In spite of its restrictive name the Faculty of Philosophy offers programmes for students of the humanities and a number of social sciences disciplines and with its 5.500 students is in fact a small university in itself. LIS studies were first introduced in 1976 as a two-year basic professional programme offered to the students enrolled in another major programme at any faculty in Croatia. Ten years later, in 1986, a new four-year programme of information sciences was introduced for students of librarianship, archival studies, museum studies, and information science. Courses offered in the first two years were obligatory for all students, and in the third year students had to opt for a stream of their choice. In other words it was only in their third year that students decided whether they were going to take librarianship, archival, museum or information science group of subjects.
The librarianship programme offered traditional core subjects, such as library management, bibliographic organisation and control, classification and subject indexing, information sources and services and history of libraries, and a number of electives, such as sociology of the book and reading, introduction to thesauri, slavic paleography, special or public or school libraries, etc. In the beginning of the nineties a revised four-year programme for students of librarianship, archival studies, museum studies and information science was submitted to the educational authorities. The programme was made up of four separate programmes for four distinctive streams taught at the department. However, a number of subjects was to be taken by students of all four streams. The referees who evaluated the programme were nominated by the educational authorities. In their report they emphasized the importance of LIS studies, but their appraisal of the museum studies and archival studies programmes was not quite favourable. A heated debate among the faculty followed. In the meantime we have all become aware of the tremendous changes introduced by the new information and telecommunication technology and the new opportunities the technology offers to educational institutions. Therefore we decided to take into consideration all external changes taking place in the education field and make a thorough revision of all our programmes. The revised programme was submitted to the authorities in the early summer of 1999 and we have been expecting their response.
A two-year postgraduate programme leading to an academic master’s degree was first introduced in 1993 and opened to students who had graduated in LIS, but also to applicants without degrees in LIS sciences. These applicants must be employed in a library or have some practical experience in it, and prior to admittance are required to pass an entrance examination. The aim of the postgraduate programme is to prepare students for research in the LIS field. A number of library directors and heads of library departments were among the first candidates enrolled in this programme.
Although there is no doctoral programme offered at present, it is possible to submit and defend a dissertation. Doctoral degree is considered to be the highest academic degree and top managers in libraries are most likely to have it. It is normally required for university teachers as well. The university authorities have recently decided that doctoral programme must be a component part of postgraduate programme. Thus, students who finish their two-year postgraduate studies and earn their master’s degree, will be able, but not obliged, to continue their studies for one more year and submit their dissertation.
At present the faculty of the Department of Information Sciences are confronted with a number of questions and dilemmas. It is quite obvious that the curriculum has to be changed and adapted to new needs. We have been avid readers of new Council of Europe documents regarding the information society and the changes it brings about. New professional profiles and new competencies required to perform new jobs are well-understood (Council of Europe, 1998c). But the real environment in which our students come to live and work has not yet much changed. Libraries are still struggling with automation of basic library functions, relying mainly on the home-made computer applications. A number of public, academic and school libraries have not yet been touched by automation. Electronic publications are scarce and libraries have not yet started processing them like other library materials. Librarians are not autonomous in the selection of library materials, because of the state policy of subsidising publishers by selecting the titles and buying them for libraries. Financial constraints are great and it is difficult for libraries to buy equipment, train staff and acquire materials. Librarians’ salaries are low and at present no trade union takes proper care of them. The reorganisation of a number of public libraries which at present function as departments of Public Universities or Houses of Culture but which, according to the Law on Libraries enacted in 1997, have to become independent institutions is still pending. The internal reorganisation of many large libraries, the National and University Library in Zagreb included, is expected to improve the number and quality of the services offered to users.
The present situation in libraries makes a great impact on our students. For quite some time now we have been aware that our students, although some of them have gradually advanced to posts of library directors or heads of departments, have difficulties in instigating changes to the traditional practice in libraries. There is no doubt that some of our students have succeeded in improving their working environment. But we have also noticed the counter influence that traditional library environment makes upon a number of our students. Once they get the job in a library many of them seem not only to adapt themselves quickly to the poor conditions, but they also accept without questioning the practice set in the library, which has not always been harmonised with professional standards they learn about during their studies. Since I have been teaching cataloguing standards I know how much care I put into the interpretation of the standards and establishing the rationale for them. But during my occasional visits to libraries and talks with my former students I came to realise how difficult it is to make a real change. I also understood that something important must have been missing from my lectures. I told my students what they had to do and why; I did not tell them how they could implement what they had learned in the surroundings they had to live and work in.
The idea that a new course in the curriculum, which would include the basics of library legislation and professional ethics, might be useful to students and make them more aware of their rights and responsibilities as well as of the rights and responsibilities of their users, occurred to me some time ago. The real impetus came two years ago from a student who prepared her final thesis. In the thesis she described automated book lending system used in a public library network in Zagreb. In her paper the student enclosed a facsimile of a list of borrowers and the titles they borrowed. The list contained names of real users along with the book titles they borrowed, and the notes about the overdue books and fines they had to pay. I expressed my wonder that the student was allowed to copy such a document. Then I realised that she did not quite understand my reproach. The idea that data about the books one reads might belong to a sphere of privacy and should be protected never occurred to her. I realised that it was not enough to impart technical knowledge and that it takes more to make a professional (2).
The issue of users' privacy belongs to the professional ethics domain. In the early nineties, when we were discussing our present curriculum, a number of library schools offered a separate course on library ethics. Our departmental library still keeps several printed booklets issued in the beginning of the nineties by LIS schools. A course entitled Information ethics was taught at the University of Maryland College of Library and Information Services (1992). The University of New South Wales Faculty of Professional Studies (1992?) offered the course of the same name. In some schools, however, professional ethics was taught as a part of a broader course. For instance, the School of Library and Information Science of the Catholic University of America offered to its students a course on Libraries and information in society (1992). The short description of the course included a discussion of the role of library and information professionals and institutions in the past and present, discussion of standards governing ethical professional conduct, exploration of the various aspects of access to information, and discussion of funding patterns. An interesting course was offered by the University of Toronto Faculty of Library and Information Science to its PhD students. The course entitled The Library in the Political Process included an investigation of the nature and importance of political forces in the governance of libraries and in the behaviour of librarians, and an examination of the activities of various pressure groups, such as library associations, book publishers and book sellers (University of Toronto, 1990; 26).
In the beginning of the nineties, however, legal and ethical issues related to the library environment in Croatia were regarded as supplementary to the core and they were incorporated in the course in library management. It should be added here that it was only in 1992 that the Croatian Library Association adopted its first Code of Ethics (Croatian Library Association, 1992)
Since at the time when I first started thinking about the new course, the reshaping of the curriculum was out of question, I used the opportunity allowed to the faculty to introduce a new course. In order to do this I had to give up teaching one of my previous courses, because the total number of hours approved for the whole programme had to be respected. The course could not consist of more than 30 hours in order to be considered ‘a slight change’ to the curriculum, for which no special administrative procedure is required apart from the agreement of the faculty. I had to write an outline of the proposed course and explain its aim. A random search of the LIS schools' curricula on the Internet revealed that a number of schools had introduced at least one course related to societal and/or legal aspects of information. (Catholic University of America, 1999; City University London, 1999; Université Libre de Bruxelles, 1999; University of Central England, 1999; University of Loughborough, 1999; University of Sheffield, 1999; University of Toronto, 1999). The titles of courses such as Libraries and information in the society, Information systems and the information society, Libraries, information and society, Information and its social contexts, Media law, Legal and professional issues point to the relation between the LIS field and its wider environment. The content of the courses normally includes elements of professional ethics, but the courses typically cover a wide range of societal and legal issues relevant to library and information institutions and professionals.
The Internet search encouraged me to broaden the scope of the new course and make it cover a variety of relatively recent issues relevant for the LIS field. I chose the name Library legislation and standards. First I wanted the students to become aware of the fact that apart from the Law on Libraries (1997) there are other laws and legal regulations which shape the library environment. I wanted to make them attentive to any part of legislation related to libraries in any possible way. I also wanted to introduce to them a few relevant documents adopted by various international bodies. My main aim was to try to induce students to think about the role of libraries in a larger context and appraise critically library legislation and standards.
I decided to structure the course as a series of seven sessions of four hours each. Two hours in each session would be used for lectures and another two hours for students’ presentations of assignments. Each of the seven sessions was to be centred on one topic. A lecture would start with relevant international documents covering the topic, followed by a description of the institutional practice abroad and then the Croatian Constitution and the respective national law(s) would be interpreted as well as the national practice. Assignments would be given to students to investigate particular issues and they would be required to have 10-15 minutes presentations in the classroom.
The seven sessions would cover the following topics, not necessarily in this order.
In this session the relevant text describing international trends is UNESCO Manifesto for Public Libraries (1994). The emphasis is on need to organise services for various categories of users, including blind and physically impaired people, prisoners, hospital patients, people living in isolated rural areas, as well as ethnic minorities. Students have to find out how the new Law on Libraries of Croatia (1997) deals with this issue. Council of Europe Recommendation on Library legislation in Europe (1999) is presented as another document of potential significance for all European libraries. Since the Recommendation covers a number of topics that are discussed in other sessions, such as copyright, freedom of access to information, etc., it is referred to in other sessions as well. M. Ryynänen's report on the Role of libraries in the modern world (1998), that gave impetus to the drafting of the Recommendation is also mentioned. The Law on High Education (1993) and the Law on Scientific Research (1993) contain stipulations on libraries and librarians that are discussed. Available library statutes and rules of proceeding are examined and interpreted in order to find out how libraries serve the public. Lack of written selection policies in libraries is pointed out.
UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948) and European Convention on Human Rights (1950)>are the two principal international documents students have to know about. The articles of the Constitution of the Republic of Croatia (1991), which guarantee freedom of expression, freedom of press and other means of communication and freedom of speech, are interpreted. The abstract issue of human rights must be connected to the specific library world. An assignment is given to a student to trace in what form these rights are introduced in the Library Law. The Croatian Library Association Statute (1992)and its Code of Ethics (1992) are introduced as texts relevant to the profession. They are compared to codes of conduct of other professions and/or other library associations. The work of IFLA/FAIFE (1999) in this field is described.
Are the rules on freedom of expression in the book world applicable to the digital world? Excerpts from a report prepared for the Council of Europe (1998b) on freedom of expression and public access points are used for discussion. The use of filters on the Internet is explained and discussed. The local situation is investigated. The state Regulation on the Foundation of the Croatian Academic and Research Network (CARNet) (1995) is presented to students. The lack of national legislation covering digital world is discussed. An assignment is given to a student to find the CARNet Rules of conduct (1995) on Internet. Netiquette guidelines as an informal standard of behaving on the network is a good enticement to discuss the style of written messages, indicate differences between style of written letters and e-mail messages, and emphasise ethical issues related to the communication in the digital world.
The Constitution of the Republic of Croatia (1991) and the Law on Public Communication (1996) are both relevant to the issue of freedom of expression and can be good starting points to discuss censorship. Censorship in libraries has a long history and in this course only those aspects of it which are relevant to present-day libraries are dealt with. Recommended literature includes works of Rauch (1993) and Malley (1993).
Privacy as a constitutional right is discussed. It is pointed out that the right to privacy is confirmed in the European Convention on Human Rights. The Council of Europe (1981) Convention concerning protection of individuals with regard to automatic processing of personal data and the EU Directive on the protection of personal data (1998) are mentioned. The national Law on protection of confidential data (1996) is interpreted. Professional, state and military secret is defined as it appears in the national legislation. The treatment of personal data kept in government databases, databases of large firms, and archives although not directly connected to libraries are considered important and explained. Selected excerpts from works of McLeod & Cooling (1990) and Marett (1991) are offered to students who have to prepare their assignments.
Protection of authors’ works guaranteed in the Constitution is another topic for discussion. International conventions like Berne Convention and Universal Convention are introduced and the relevant articles of the Croatian Copyright Law (1998) presented. The concept of lending right, not known in Croatia, is explained. Possible reasons for limiting photocopying in libraries are put forward. The rights of producers and reproductive artists are interpreted because they are relevant for public libraries, which hold collections of sound recordings. The need to establish a balance between author’s rights to remuneration and users’ right to free access is emphasised. Selected chapters from Marett (1991) are used in preparing the lecture.
The fact that libraries hold a part of the country’s cultural heritage is explained. The activities and some documents of the Council of Europe (1998a) in this field are outlined. Legal deposit is shown to be a means to protect the written heritage. Problems related to the legal deposit of electronic materials are discussed. Relevant parts of the Law on Libraries are examined. Law on protection and preservation of cultural heritage (1999) and various professional texts on preservation and conservation in libraries and archives are examined and interpreted. Relevant parts of the Criminal Law (1997) concerning illegal export of cultural heritage are interpreted.
It should be kept in mind that a number of issues dealt with in this course are by no means new to students. Issues like organisation of libraries, legal deposit or preservation of cultural heritage appear as topics in other courses as well. In this course, however, technical aspects have intentionally been put aside and legal and ethical aspects only have been considered. The intention has been to make students aware of the existence of international documents of relevance to the library community and to show how the international trends and attitudes have been followed at the national level. The existence or lack of adequate national legislation has been investigated and possible differences in the international and national treatment of particular issues explained. Ethical aspects have also been underlined. It is hoped that the course might help students to improve their understanding of the legal context in which they are going to work and teach them to appreciate the importance of good legislation. It is also hoped that students will be able to recognise basic moral principles of the profession and could rely on them in their future work.
(1) In 1998 a new programme for librarians was established at the Faculty of Pedagogy, University of Osijek. The programme is a slightly revised four-year programme offered by the Department of Information Sciences in Zagreb and the Zagreb faculty travel to Osijek to teach.(2) It is only fair to add here that some twenty years ago when I started working as a librarian in the National and University Library in Zagreb, I learned from my superiors that the titles of books one reads were not to be revealed to another user. Why this important part of professional ethics has been forgotten, remains to be explained.
How to cite this paper:
Horvat,Aleksandra (2000) "Library legislation and free access to information as new topics in library and information science education" Information Research, 5(2) Available at: http://informationr.net/ir/5-2/paper72.html
© the author, 2000. Last updated: 5th January 2000